AGV vs AMR: which mobile robot fits your operation?

Abstract illustration for: AGV vs AMR: which mobile robot fits your operation?

Both AGVs and AMRs are mobile robots that move materials without a driver. The difference is how they find their way, and that affects cost, flexibility and how they behave around people.

The short answer

An AGV (automated guided vehicle) follows a guide: magnetic tape, floor markers, wires or reflectors. It drives the route you gave it and stops if something blocks the way.

An AMR (autonomous mobile robot) builds a map with sensors such as lidar and cameras, then plans its own path. If something blocks the way, it drives around it.

Side by side

AGVAMR
NavigationFollows tape, markers or wiresPlans its own path from a map
ObstaclesStops and waitsDrives around
Route changesMove the tape, update the mapUpdate the map in software
PredictabilityVery highLower: paths vary
Heavy loadsCommon, up to tonnesMostly lighter loads
Typical costLower for simple routesHigher per unit

When an AGV is the better fit

  • Routes are fixed and repeated. Line-side supply, hospital meal runs and dispatch moves happen along the same path all day.
  • Loads are heavy. Towing trolley trains or lifting pallets is classic AGV work. BeeBotic AGVs handle 100 kg to 1.5 tonnes.
  • People need to know where the robot goes. In narrow corridors and busy aisles, a predictable path is a safety feature.
  • Doors, lifts and conveyors are on the route. Fixed stations make it simple to connect equipment through I/O, as our Heartbeat system does.
  • Lower cost. For a handful of fixed routes, an AGV is usually the lower total cost.

When an AMR is the better fit

  • Destinations change from trip to trip, such as order picking across a large warehouse.
  • The layout changes every week.
  • Loads are light and the floor is open.

The "AGVs are inflexible" myth

Older AGVs ran on wires cut into the floor, and changing a route meant construction work. Magnetic tape changed that. Moving a tape route takes hours, not weeks, and the stations and workflows are changed in software. For most factories and hospitals, routes change a few times a year at most, so this is rarely a real limit.

Can you mix them?

Yes. Some sites run AGVs on the heavy, repeated routes and AMRs for picking. One system should then manage traffic and jobs for both, so vehicles do not block each other. Our AGV fleet management software handles traffic control for AGV fleets.

Cost over the life of the robot

Purchase price is only part of the comparison. Over a typical ten-year life, look at:

  • Installation: AGVs need tape or markers laid, AMRs need the site mapped. Both take a few days for a simple site.
  • Changes: moving tape costs some hours of work; changing an AMR map is mostly software. If your routes change monthly, this adds up in favour of AMRs. If they change once a year, it hardly matters.
  • Maintenance: AGVs have simpler sensors and fewer parts that need calibration. Heavy-duty AGV drives are built for long service.
  • Downtime: a predictable route means fewer surprises. An AMR that keeps finding a new detour around a blocked aisle can be slower than an AGV that waits a few seconds.

Safety in mixed traffic

Both types slow down and stop for people. The difference is behaviour. Staff learn an AGV's route in a day and keep it clear. An AMR may appear from different directions, which some workers find harder to predict in narrow aisles. In hospitals and busy production areas, that predictability is one reason AGVs remain common.

Three real situations

Hospital meal delivery. Same kitchen, same wards, same times every day, with lifts and fire doors on the way. AGV.

E-commerce picking. Every order goes to different shelves, and the layout changes with the season. AMR.

Factory line-side supply. Stores to the same lines all day, heavy carts. AGV, often with call buttons at each line.

How to decide

List your material movements and mark each one: fixed or variable route, light or heavy, how many trips per day. If most of the volume is fixed and heavy, start with AGVs. If most of it is variable and light, look at AMRs.

Not sure? Send us your list and we will tell you honestly which trips suit an AGV. Read more in What is an AGV?

Frequently asked questions

Is an AMR better than an AGV?

Neither is better in general. AGVs suit fixed, repeated routes; AMRs suit routes that change often. Many sites use both.

Can an AGV avoid obstacles?

An AGV stops or slows for obstacles but does not drive around them, because it stays on its guided route.

Which is cheaper, an AGV or an AMR?

For simple fixed routes, AGVs are usually cheaper to buy and maintain. AMRs cost more but need less floor work when routes change.