Choosing an automation company in Malaysia: 10 questions to ask (and how to check AGV ROI)

Abstract illustration for: Choosing an automation company in Malaysia: 10 questions to ask (and how to check AGV ROI)

Choosing an automation partner is a long-term decision. An AGV or robot should run for ten years or more, so the company behind it matters as much as the machine. We would ask these questions in your position.

10 questions to ask any automation company

  1. Have you done a project like mine? Ask for examples in your industry and with similar loads and routes.
  2. Do you design and build, or resell? Builders can adapt the design to your site. Resellers depend on the manufacturer.
  3. Who services it, and how fast? Ask where the engineers are based and what response time they commit to.
  4. Are spare parts held in Malaysia? Waiting weeks for a part from abroad means weeks of downtime.
  5. Can it connect to my systems? ERP, WMS, doors, lifts, conveyors. Ask exactly how it connects.
  6. Who changes the routes later? Can your team do it in software, or do you need a service visit every time?
  7. What data will I get? Trips, utilisation, downtime, battery health. If you cannot measure it, you cannot prove the payback.
  8. What is the design life? And what maintenance does it need to get there?
  9. What does training cover? Operators, supervisors and your maintenance team.
  10. What is not in the quote? Floor work, network, door controls, integration and maintenance are often extra.

How to work out AGV payback

A simple model with four numbers is enough.

1. The cost of the work today

For the trips the AGV will take over, add up per year:

  • Labour: people times hours on these trips times hourly cost, for every shift.
  • Overtime and temporary staff at peaks.
  • Hiring and training cost from staff turnover.
  • Damage to goods, carts, doors and walls from manual handling.

2. The cost of the AGV

  • Vehicles, attachments, chargers, guidance and software.
  • Integration with doors, lifts or systems.
  • Yearly maintenance, for example a lifetime service contract.

3. What it frees up

The people who pushed trolleys move to work that adds value. That is often worth more than the labour saving itself, but count it separately so your payback stays honest.

4. The payback

Payback in years = AGV investment / (yearly cost of the manual work minus yearly AGV running cost).

Remember that an AGV can run every shift. A trip that takes three people across three shifts is a very different case from one person on one shift.

Red flags

  • A price before anyone has looked at your site.
  • No clear answer on service and spare parts.
  • Routes that only the supplier can change.
  • No data or reporting.
  • No mention of training.

A simple payback example

The method below uses illustrative steps. Put in your own figures.

  • Two people spend most of each shift moving materials on one route, over two shifts. That is four people's time on this task.
  • If each person costs your company a certain amount per year including benefits and overtime, multiply by four. Add damage and turnover costs.
  • Subtract the yearly service cost of the AGV. The result is the yearly saving.
  • Divide the AGV investment by the yearly saving. That is your payback in years.

Because AGVs are designed for ten years or more, a payback of a few years leaves a long period of net savings. If the AGV runs three shifts instead of two, the saving grows while the investment stays the same.

What a good proposal looks like

  • A route drawing with stations, doors, lifts and charging points.
  • Vehicle type, attachment and payload for each route.
  • How jobs are triggered and what systems are connected.
  • Installation steps and timeline.
  • Training plan for operators and maintenance staff.
  • Service terms: response time, inspections, parts and safety checks.
  • A clear list of what is excluded.

If two proposals look very different in price, check the exclusions first. That is usually where the difference hides.

How BeeBotic answers these questions

We design, fabricate and assemble AGVs in Cyberjaya. Routes and stations are set in our fleet software, so your team can change them. The Heartbeat system connects doors, lifts and conveyors and reports every AGV's health. And our Lifetime Service Program covers inspections, spare parts, safety checks and retraining for the life of the vehicle.

Ask us for a site survey and we will put real numbers on your payback. More reading: factory automation in Malaysia.

Frequently asked questions

How long is the payback on an AGV?

It depends on how many shifts it runs and what work it replaces. Work it out from your own labour, damage and downtime costs using the method in this article.

Should I buy from a local or international automation company?

Either can work. What matters is local service, spare parts in the country and engineers who can respond quickly.

What should an AGV quote include?

Vehicles, attachments, guidance installation, chargers, software, integration with doors or systems, training, and the maintenance terms.